

C12 Quantum Electronics, a French startup founded in 2020, is pioneering a revolutionary approach to quantum computing using carbon nanotubes. Their technology aims to harness the quantum properties of nuclear spins within a carbon lattice, potentially offering a unique combination of long coherence times and scalability.
At the core of C12's quantum architecture are isotopically purified carbon nanotubes. These nanotubes are composed primarily of carbon-12, an isotope with zero nuclear spin. This isotopic purification is crucial for creating an ultra-clean quantum environment. The nanotubes, typically 1-2 nm in diameter and up to several micrometers in length, serve as nanoscale scaffolds for the qubit system.
The qubits in C12's system are individual nuclear spins, likely from atoms such as carbon-13 or phosphorus-31, embedded in or attached to the carbon nanotube. These nuclear spins exhibit exceptionally long coherence times, potentially extending into the range of seconds or even minutes. This is due to their weak coupling to the environment, a property enhanced by the surrounding spin-zero carbon-12 lattice.
The quantum states of these nuclear spin qubits are typically the spin-up and spin-down states, corresponding to the two possible orientations of the nuclear spin in an external magnetic field. The energy splitting between these states, known as the Zeeman splitting, is given by ΔE = γℏB, where γ is the gyromagnetic ratio of the nucleus, ℏ is the reduced Planck constant, and B is the external magnetic field strength.
C12's quantum processor operates at ultra-low temperatures, likely in the range of 10-100 mK, achieved using dilution refrigerators. This extreme cold is necessary to minimize thermal excitations and maximize qubit coherence. The energy scale of the thermal fluctuations (kBT) must be much smaller than the qubit energy splitting to maintain quantum coherence.
Quantum operations in C12's system are implemented through a sophisticated interplay of magnetic resonance techniques and electrical control. Single-qubit gates are likely achieved using oscillating magnetic fields in the radio frequency (RF) range, resonant with the nuclear spin transition frequency. The Rabi frequency of these operations, which determines the gate speed, is given by Ω = γB1/2, where B1 is the amplitude of the oscillating field.
Two-qubit gates, crucial for creating entanglement, might be implemented through various mechanisms. One possibility is dipolar coupling between neighboring nuclear spins, with an interaction strength proportional to (μ0/4π)(γ1γ2ℏ2/r3), where μ0 is the vacuum permeability, γ1 and γ2 are the gyromagnetic ratios of the interacting nuclei, and r is their separation. Another approach could involve electron-mediated coupling, where electron spins associated with the nanotubes serve as intermediaries to couple distant nuclear spins.
The carbon nanotube itself plays a crucial role in the qubit system beyond just hosting the nuclear spins. It acts as a nanoscale electrode, allowing for electrical manipulation and readout of the qubit states. This is likely achieved through the hyperfine interaction between the nuclear spins and conduction electrons in the nanotube. The hyperfine coupling strength can be on the order of MHz, allowing for fast electrical control and readout.
C12's approach to qubit readout might involve spin-to-charge conversion techniques. By applying appropriate voltage pulses to the nanotube, the spin state of a nearby nucleus can influence the tunneling of electrons, which can then be detected as a change in current through the nanotube. This process can potentially be enhanced using quantum point contacts or single-electron transistors integrated with the nanotube structure.
One of the most significant challenges in C12's technology is achieving single-atom precision in qubit placement. This likely involves sophisticated nanofabrication techniques, possibly including ion implantation or chemical functionalization of the nanotubes. The precise positioning of qubits is crucial for maintaining uniformity in qubit properties and enabling controlled interactions.
Scaling up the number of qubits in C12's system presents both opportunities and challenges. The one-dimensional nature of carbon nanotubes could potentially allow for the creation of arrays of parallel nanotubes, each hosting multiple qubits. However, managing interactions between an increasing number of qubits while maintaining individual addressability will require advanced control techniques and possibly the use of auxiliary qubits for mediating longer-range interactions.
In the realm of quantum error correction, C12 might explore codes that leverage the long coherence times of their qubits. For example, they could implement decoherence-free subspaces by encoding logical qubits in collective states of multiple physical qubits that are insensitive to certain types of noise. The potential for high-fidelity operations in their system could also make surface codes or other topological quantum error correction schemes viable with lower overhead than in noisier qubit platforms.
As C12 Quantum Electronics continues to advance their technology, they are pushing the boundaries of what's possible in quantum computing. Their unique approach, combining the long coherence of nuclear spins with the scalability of carbon nanotubes, offers a promising path towards fault-tolerant quantum computation. If successful, their technology could be particularly powerful for quantum algorithms that require deep circuits or long coherence times, potentially enabling new frontiers in quantum simulation and quantum error correction.